CRR takes the FDA to Court

When it comes to emergency contraception, the FDA (Food and Drug Administration) has a questionable past. Back in 1999 the FDA approved Plan B as emergency contraception by prescription only. At the Start of 2001 the Center for Reproductive Rights filed a Citizen Petition to have them reconsider this and make it available as an OTC (over-the-counter) medication and two years after the Plan B’s manufacturer filed a petition with the FDA to get OTC status.

While a panel of FDA experts recommended approval of OTC status, the head of the office in charge of the final decision told his employees that normal procedure would not be followed and they would not be making the decision. The FDA then denied the application and recommended the manufacturer re-file the application for OTC status for women over 16 only. Pretty shady huh? Well while all this was going on the head of this department Dr. Steven Galson, told a colleague that he had to deny the application or risk losing his job. Also during the time, the second most important person at the FDA during this time Dr. Janet Woodcock told a colleague that they have to deny the application and later approve it with an age restriction to “appease the administration’s constituents.”  They manufacturer did re-file with an age restriction did but by 2005 the FDA still had not approved it.

The Center for Reproductive Rights then filed a lawsuit against the FDA for letting politics determine their decisions instead of science. In 2006, with the lawsuit still pending, the FDA approved Plan B for women 18 and older as an OTC medication. In 2009 a New York court orders the FDA to approve Plan B for women 17 and older without a prescription and to reconsider the Citizen Petition filed in 2001. Also in 2009 the FDA approves Plan B, the new Plan B One-Step, and Next Choice ( a generic brand of Plan B) for women 17 and older without prescriptions but still requiring them for women 16 and under. In 2010 a new brand of emergency contraception Ella, is approved for women by prescription only. The Center for Reproductive Rights filed a motion to have the FDA found in contempt of court for failing to reconsider the Citizens Petition.

This ten year back and forth seems poised to be ended by the end of this year. The motion to have the FDA held in contempt of court will be heard on December 13. While the hearing relates specifically to Plan B the Center for Reproductive Rights has an online petition going to have the FDA also remove the age restriction and prescription requirement from Ella. That is a lot of information so if you’re interested in seeing it in a timeline check out this page on the CRR’s website. While you’re at it sign their petition to get all emergency contraception approved for OTC sale as well including Ella.


Tagged: , , , ,

3 thoughts on “CRR takes the FDA to Court

  1. […] As we mentioned earlier, the FDA has a complicated past with Plan B. This week they were supposed to announce a major overhaul in that relationship and finally approving it for OTC status for women of all ages. This means anyone who had unprotected sex could purchase it without having to get a prescription or be told “no I don’t believe in using contraceptives” by a judgmental pharmacist. Apparently the Secretary of Health and Human Services Kathleen Sebelius did not agree with the FDA’s intended decision so she used her power as head of the HHS to override the decision; something no prior Secretary has done. […]

  2. […] you have been following our blog for awhile you may have read an article from a few weeks ago about the FDA’s long history with Plan B and other emergency contraceptives. In it we mentioned that the Center for Reproductive Rights filed suit to have the FDA held in […]

  3. […]                 Teva, the pharmaceutical company that manufactures Plan B has been attempting to get Plan B approved for over the counter status for over a decade. The Center for Reproductive Rights has been assisting them as they pursued lawsuits seeking interventions from the court system when it became clear that the FDA was putting political ideologies above science. The full background is a little complex so if you want the long version read our earlier posts regar… […]

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: